| GOALS | ||
| Overall | 85 | Mario Lemieux (1988-89) |
| Center | 85 | Mario Lemieux (1988-89) |
| Right Wing | 62 | Jaromir Jagr (1995-96) |
| Left Wing | 55 | Kevin Stevens (1992-93) |
| Defenseman | 30 | Paul Coffey (1988-89) |
| Rookie | 43 | Mario Lemieux (1984-85) |
| Rookie Defenseman | 12 | Zarley Zalapski (1988-89) |
| Goaltender | 1 | Alex Nedeljkovic (2024-25) |
| Tristan Jarry (2023-24) | ||
| ASSISTS | ||
| Overall | 114 | Mario Lemieux (1988-89) |
| Center | 114 | Mario Lemieux (1988-89) |
| Right Wing | 87 | Jaromir Jagr (1995-96) |
| Left Wing | 69 | Kevin Stevens (1991-92) |
| Defenseman | 83 | Paul Coffey (1988-89) |
| Rookie | 63 | Sidney Crosby (2005-06) |
| Rookie Defenseman | 33 | Zarley Zalapski (1988-89) |
| Goaltender | 8 | Tom Barrasso (1992-93) |
| POINTS | ||
| Overall | 199 | Mario Lemieux (1988-89) |
| Center | 199 | Mario Lemieux (1988-89) |
| Right Wing | 149 | Jaromir Jagr (1995-96) |
| Left Wing | 123 | Kevin Stevens (1991-92) |
| Defenseman | 113 | Paul Coffey (1988-89) |
| Rookie | 102 | Sidney Crosby (2005-06) |
| Rookie Defenseman | 45 | Zarley Zalapski (1988-89) |
| Goaltender | 8 | Tom Barrasso (1992-93) |
| PENALTIES IN MINUTES | ||
| Overall | 409 | Paul Baxter (1981-82) |
| Center | 157 | Dave Hannan (1988-89) |
| Right Wing | 285 | Jay Caufield (1988-89) |
| Left Wing | 378 | Dave Schultz (1977-78) |
| Defenseman | 409 | Paul Baxter (1981-82) |
| Rookie | 285 | Jay Caufield (1988-89) |
| Rookie Defenseman | 224 | Marty McSorley (1983-84) |
| Goaltender | 60 | Andy Brown (1973-74) |
| POWER-PLAY GOALS | ||
| Overall | 31 | Mario Lemieux (1988-89, 1995-96) |
| Center | 31 | Mario Lemieux (1988-89, 1995-96) |
| Right Wing | 24 | Rob Brown (1988-89) |
| Left Wing | 26 | Kevin Stevens (1992-93) |
| Defenseman | 13 | Kevin Hatcher (1997-98) |
| Doug Bodger (1987-88) | ||
| Rookie | 16 | Evgeni Malkin (2006-07) |
| Sidney Crosby (2005-06) | ||
| Rookie Defenseman | 5 | Zarley Zalapski (1988-89) |
| POWER-PLAY ASSISTS | ||
| Overall | 58 | Mario Lemieux (1987-88) |
| Center | 58 | Mario Lemieux (1987-88) |
| Right Wing | 34 | Jaromir Jagr (1998-99) |
| Left Wing | 27 | Pat Boutette (1981-82) |
| Defenseman | 53 | Paul Coffey (1988-89) |
| Rookie | 31 | Sidney Crosby (2005-06) |
| Rookie Defenseman | 23 | Zarley Zalapski (1988-89) |
| POWER-PLAY POINTS | ||
| Overall | 80 | Mario Lemieux (1987-88) |
| Center | 80 | Mario Lemieux (1987-88) |
| Right Wing | 51 | Jaromir Jagr (1995-96) |
| Left Wing | 44 | Kevin Stevens (1992-93) |
| Defenseman | 64 | Paul Coffey (1988-89) |
| Rookie | 47 | Sidney Crosby (2005-06) |
| Rookie Defenseman | 28 | Zarley Zalapski (1988-89) |
| SHORTHANDED GOALS | ||
| Overall | 13 | Mario Lemieux (1988-89) |
| Center | 13 | Mario Lemieux (1988-89) |
| Right Wing | 4 | Pascal Dupuis (2010-11) |
| Rick Tocchet (1992-93) | ||
| Jean Pronovost (1973-74) | ||
| Left Wing | 5 | Ryan Malone (2005-06) |
| Defenseman | 2 | Kevin Hatcher (1998-99) |
| Darius Kasparaitis (1997-98) | ||
| Sergei Zubov (1995-96) | ||
| Larry Murphy (1991-92, 1992-93) | ||
| Grant Jennings (1991-92) | ||
| Paul Coffey (1987-88) | ||
| Moe Mantha (1985-86) | ||
| Bob Woytowich (1968-69) | ||
| Rookie | 7 * | Jordan Staal (2006-07) |
| * - NHL Record | ||
| SHOTS ON GOAL | ||
| Overall | 403 | Jaromir Jagr (1995-96) |
| Center | 382 | Mario Lemieux (1987-88) |
| Right Wing | 403 | Jaromir Jagr (1995-96) |
| Left Wing | 329 | James Neal (329) |
| Defenseman | 342 | Paul Coffey (1988-89) |
| Rookie | 278 | Sidney Crosby (2005-06) |
| Rookie Defenseman | 156 | Darryl Edestrand (1971-72) |
| MOST CONSECUTIVE GAMES WITH A… | ||
| Goal | 12 | Mario Lemieux (18 goals) |
| October 6, 1992 to November 1, 1992 | ||
| Assist | 16 | Jaromir Jagr (24 assists) |
| January 9, 2001 to February 16, 2001 | ||
| Point | 46 | Mario Lemieux (39g, 64a, 103 points) |
| October 31, 1989 to February 14, 1990 | ||
| Goal (Rookie) | 7 | Mike Bullard (8 goals) |
| January 23, 1982 to February 6, 1982 | ||
| Assist (Rookie) | 6 | Sidney Crosby (7 assists) |
| October 5, 2005 to October 15, 2005 | ||
| Mario Lemieux (9 assists) | ||
| December 7, 1984 to December 21, 1984 | ||
| October 27, 1984 to November 8, 1984 | ||
| Point (Rookie) | 11 | Mike Bullard (3g, 10a, 13 points) |
| December 12, 1981 to January 3, 1982 | ||
| Goals | 18 | Mario Lemieux (March 1993) |
| Assists | 25 | Mario Lemieux (March 1988) |
| Points | 38 | Mario Lemieux (October 1988) |
| (11 games - 16g - 22a) |
| Goals | 5 | Mario Lemieux (3 times) |
| March 26, 1996 - vs. St. Louis | ||
| April 9, 1993 - at NY Rangers | ||
| December 31, 1988 - vs. New Jersey | ||
| Assists | 6 | Kris Letang |
| December 27, 2023 - at NY Islanders | ||
| Mario Lemieux (3 times) | ||
| November 1, 1995 - vs. Tampa Bay | ||
| December 5, 1992 - at San Jose | ||
| October 15, 1988 - vs. St. Louis | ||
| Greg Malone | ||
| November 28, 1979 - vs. Quebec | ||
| Ron Stackhouse | ||
| March 8, 1975 - vs. Philadelphia | ||
| Points | 8 | Mario Lemieux (2 times) |
| December 31, 1988 - vs. New Jersey | ||
| October 15, 1988 - vs. St. Louis | ||
| Shots | 14 | Ron Stackhouse |
| April 3, 1976 - vs. Washington | ||
| Penalties | 9 | Russ Anderson |
| January 19, 1980 - vs. Edmonton | ||
| Penalty Minutes | 51 | Russ Anderson |
| January 19, 1980 - vs. Edmonton |
| Goals | 4 | Mario Lemieux (3rd period) |
| January 26, 1997 - at Montreal | ||
| Assists | 5 | Kris Letang (2nd period) |
| December 27, 2023 - at NY Islanders | ||
| Points | 5 | Kris Letang (2nd period) |
| December 27, 2023 - at NY Islanders | ||
| Shots | 9 | Evgeni Malkin (2nd period) |
| October 30, 2008 - at Phoenix | ||
| Penalties | 8 | Russ Anderson (2nd period) |
| January 19, 1980 - vs. Edmonton | ||
| Penalty Minutes | 46 | Russ Anderson (2nd period) |
| January 19, 1980 - vs. Edmonton |
| GAMES PLAYED | ||
| All-Time | 691 | Marc-Andre Fleury |
| Season | 67 | Marc-Andre Fleury (2011-12) |
| Marc-Andre Fleury (2009-10) | ||
| Marc-Andre Fleury (2006-07) | ||
| Season, Home | 37 | Marc-Andre Fleury (2006-07) |
| Johan Hedberg (2001-02) | ||
| Season, Road | 34 | Marc-Andre Fleury (2009-10) |
| MINUTES PLAYED | ||
| All-Time | 39,771:44 | Marc-Andre Fleury |
| Season | 3,905:28 | Marc-Andre Fleury (2006-07) |
| Season, Home | 2,188:21 | Marc-Andre Fleury (2006-07) |
| Season, Road | 1,940:38 | Marc-Andre Fleury (2009-10) |
| WINS | ||
| All-Time | 375 | Marc-Andre Fleury |
| Season | 43 | Tom Barrasso (1992-93) |
| Season, Home | 24 | Marc-Andre Fleury (2011-12) |
| Tom Barrasso (1992-93) | ||
| Season, Road | 19 | Tom Barrasso (1992-93) |
| LOSSES | ||
| All-Time | 216 | Marc-Andre Fleury |
| Season | 34 | Johan Hedberg (2001-02) |
| Season, Home | 18 | Johan Hedberg (2001-02) |
| Season, Road | 17 | Michel Dion (1981-82) |
| Les Binkley (1967-68) | ||
| TIES | ||
| All-Time | 53 | Tom Barrasso |
| Season | 15 | Denis Herron (1977-78) |
| Season, Home | 9 | Les Binkley (1967-68) |
| Season, Road | 7 | Greg Millen (1980-81) |
| Denis Herron (1978-79) | ||
| Denis Herron (1977-78) | ||
| SAVES | ||
| All-Time | 17,774 | Marc-Andre Fleury |
| Season | 1,915 | Denis Herron (1977-78) |
| Season, Home | 1,017 | Marc-Andre Fleury (2006-07) |
| Season, Road | 977 | Denis Herron (1977-78) |
| All-Time Per Game | 30.6 | Joe Daley |
| Season Per Game | 32.6 | Denis Herron (1977-78) |
| Season Per Game, Home | 31.2 | Joe Daley (1968-69) |
| Season Per Game, Road | 35.8 | Denis Herron (1977-78) |
| SHUTOUTS | ||
| All-Time | 44 | Marc-Andre Fleury |
| Season | 10 | Marc-Andre Fleury (2014-15) |
| Season, Home | 5 | Marc-Andre Fleury (2006-07) |
| Season, Road | 6 | Marc-Andre Fleury (2014-15) |
| Tom Barrasso (1997-98) | ||
| WINNING PERCENTAGE | ||
| All-Time (Min. 30 games) | .669 | Matt Murray (117-53-19) |
| Season (Min. 30 games) | .742 | Marc-Andre Fleury (2012-13 - 23-8-0) |
| GOALS AGAINST | ||
| All-Time | 1,713 | Marc-Andre Fleury |
| Season | 258 | Greg Millen (1980-81) |
| Season, Home | 128 | Greg Millen (1980-81) |
| Season, Road | 130 | Greg Millen (1980-81) |
| GOALS-AGAINST AVERAGE | ||
| All-Time (Min. 30 games) | 2.51 | Ty Conklin |
| Season (Min. 30 games) | 2.07 | Tom Barrasso (1997-98) |
| Season, Home | 2.02 | Al Smith (1970-71) |
| Season, Road | 1.83 | Tom Barrasso (1997-98) |
| SAVE PERCENTAGE | ||
| All-Time (Min. 30 games) | .923 | Ty Conklin |
| Season (Min. 30 games) | .923 | Matt Murray (2016-17) |
| LONGEST CONSECUTIVE STREAKS | ||
| Games Played | 26 | Greg Millen (11-10-5) |
| February 7, 1981 to April 4, 1981 | ||
| Wins | 14 | Tom Barrasso |
| March 9, 1993 to April 9, 1993 | ||
| Wins, Home | 13 | Marc-Andre Fleury |
| February 2, 2013 to April 17, 2013 | ||
| Jim Rutherford | ||
| February 16, 1972 to November 16, 1972 | ||
| Wins, Road | 8 | Tomas Vokoun |
| January 31, 2013 to April 22, 2013 | ||
| Unbeaten | 16 * | Patrick Lalime (14-0-2) |
| December 6, 1996 to January 21, 1997 | ||
| Unbeaten, Home | 18 | Michel Plasse (14-0-4) |
| January 11, 1975 to December 31, 1975 | ||
| Unbeaten, Road | 8 | Tristan Jarry (7-0-1) |
| November 24, 2021 to January 27, 2022 | ||
| Losses | 9 | Michel Dion |
| December 20, 1983 to March 1, 1984 | ||
| Losses, Home | 7 | Sebastien Caron |
| December 31, 2003 to February 10, 2004 | ||
| Losses, Road | 10 | Denis Herron |
| December 22, 1984 to March 30, 1985 | ||
| Joe Daley | ||
| November 13, 1968 to March 20, 1969 | ||
| Winless | 15 | Al Smith (0-10-5) |
| January 28, 1971 to April 1, 1971 | ||
| Winless, Home | 9 | Les Binkley (0-8-1) |
| November 6, 1968 to December 21, 1968 | ||
| Winless, Road | 26 | Al Smith (0-18-8) |
| March 5, 1970 to April 1, 1971 | ||
| * - NHL Record to begin a career | ||
| LONGEST SHUTOUT SEQUENCE | ||
| Individual | 177:15 | Tristan Jarry |
| November 29, 2019 to December 10, 2019 | ||
| Team | 218:48 | Tomas Vokoun / Marc-Andre Fleury |
| March 24, 2013 to April 2, 2013 | ||
| Against | 183:15 | January 31, 1980 to February 9, 1980 |