| MOST GOALS IN ONE GAME | ||
| PENGUINS: | 12 | March 15, 1975 in a 12-1 win vs. Washington |
| December 26, 1991 in a 12-1 win vs. Toronto | ||
| OPPONENTS: | 11 | November 25, 1992 vs. NY Rangers in an 11-3 Rangers win |
| MOST SHOTS IN ONE GAME | ||
| PENGUINS: | 65 | March 15, 1975 in a 12-1 win vs. Washington |
| OPPONENTS: | 55 | October 23, 1976 vs. Montreal in a 9-1 Canadiens win at Pittsburgh |
| MOST PENALTY MINUTES IN ONE GAME | ||
| PENGUINS: | 144 | January 19, 1980 in a 5-2 loss vs. Edmonton |
| OPPONENTS: | 123 | January 19, 1980 vs. Edmonton in a 5-2 Oilers win |
| MOST GOALS IN ONE PERIOD | ||
| PENGUINS: | 8 | December 17, 1991 (2nd period) in a 10-2 win vs. San Jose |
| OPPONENTS: | 6 | February 3, 1982 (2nd period) vs. Minnesota in a 9-6 North Stars win |
| January 12, 1983 (3rd period) vs. Minnesota in a 7-0 North Stars win | ||
| January 15, 1983 (2nd period) vs. Montreal in an 8-7 Canadiens win | ||
| January 7, 1984 (3rd period) vs. New Jersey in a 7-4 Devils win | ||
| February 16, 1985 (2nd period) vs. Quebec in an 8-1 Nordiques win | ||
| January 3, 1991 (2nd period) vs. NY Rangers in a 7-5 Rangers win | ||
| November 25, 1992 (3rd period) vs. NY Rangers in an 11-3 Rangers win | ||
| November 16, 1996 (2nd period) vs. NY Rangers in an 8-3 Rangers win | ||
| MOST GOALS IN ONE GAME | ||
| PENGUINS: | 5 | Mario Lemieux, December 31, 1988, in an 8-6 win vs. New Jersey |
| Mario Lemieux, March 26, 1996, in an 8-4 win vs. St. Louis | ||
| OPPONENTS: | 4 | Dennis Maruk (California), November 18, 1975, in a 5-3 Golden Seals win |
| Wayne Gretzky (Edmonton), February 22, 1984, in a 9-2 Oilers win | ||
| Mike Ridley (Washington), October 11, 1988, in an 8-7 Capitals loss | ||
| Randy McKay (New Jersey), October 28, 2000, in a 9-0 Devils win | ||
| John Madden (New Jersey), October 28, 2000, in a 9-0 Devils win | ||
| MOST ASSISTS IN ONE GAME | ||
| PENGUINS: | 6 | Ron Stackhouse, March 8, 1975, in an 8-2 win vs. Philadelphia |
| Greg Malone, November 28, 1979, in a 7-2 win vs. Quebec | ||
| Mario Lemieux, October 15, 1988, in a 9-2 win vs. St. Louis | ||
| Mario Lemieux, November 1, 1995, in a 10-0 win vs. Tampa Bay | ||
| OPPONENTS: | 6 | Patrik Sundstrom (Vancouver), February 29, 1984, in a 9-5 Canucks win |
| MOST POINTS IN ONE GAME | ||
| PENGUINS: | 8 | Mario Lemieux, October 15, 1988, in a 9-2 win vs. St. Louis |
| Mario Lemieux, December 31, 1988, in an 8-6 win vs. New Jersey | ||
| OPPONENTS: | 6 | Patrik Sundstrom (Vancouver), February 29, 1984, in a 9-5 Canuuks win |
| MOST PENALTIES IN MINUTES IN ONE GAME | ||
| PENGUINS: | 51 | Russ Anderson, January 19, 1980, in a 5-2 loss vs. Edmonton |
| OPPONENTS: | 34 | Dave Lumley (Edmonton), January 19, 1980, in a 5-2 Oilers win |
| MOST SAVES IN ONE GAME | ||
| PENGUINS: | 51 | Tom Barrasso, January 31, 1988, in a 4-2 win vs. Detroit |
| OPPONENTS: | 53 | Wayne Thomas (Montreal), March 10, 1974, in a 5-4 Canadiens win |