Al MacNeil

1967-68 (74 games)

John Arbour

1968-69 (17 games)

Bob Woytowich

1969-70 (64 games, 10 playoff games)
1970-71 (78 games)
1971-72 (31 games)

Tim Horton

1971-72 (27 games, 4 playoff games)

Jack Lynch

1972-73 (47 games)
​1973-74 (17 games)

Ron Stackhouse

​1973-74 (34 games)
1974-75 (72 games, 9 playoff games)
​1975-76 (80 games, 3 playoff games)
​1976-77 (80 games, 3 playoff games)
1977-78 (50 games)
1978-79 (75 games, 7 playoff games)
1979-80 (78 games, 5 playoff games)
1980-81 (74 games, 4 playoff games)
1981-82 (76 games, 1 playoff game)

Bennett Wolf

1982-83 (5 games)

Norm Schmidt

1983-84 (34 games)

Todd Charlesworth

1983-84 (4 games)

Doug Bodger

1985-86 (79 games)
1986-87 (76 games)
1987-88 (69 games)
​1988-89 (10 games)

Jim Kyte

1989-90 (56 games)
1990-91 (1 game)

Grant Jennings

1990-91 (13 games, 13 playoff games)
1991-92 (53 games, 10 playoff games)
​1992-93 (58 games, 12 playoff games)
1993-94 (61 games, 3 playoff games)
1994-95 (25 games)

Sergei Zubov

1995-96 (2 games)

Stefan Bergkvist

1995-96 (4 playoff games)
1996-97 (5 games)

Dan Trebil

1999-00 (3 games)

Marc Bergevin

2000-01 (36 games, 12 playoff games)

Jamie Pushor

2001-02 (13 games)
2002-03 (76 games)

Steve Poapst

2005-06 (21 games)

Mark Eaton

2006-07 (35 games, 5 playoff games)
​2007-08 (36 games)

Alex Goligoski

2008-09 (1 game, 2 playoff games)
​2009-10 (69 games, 13 playoff games)
​2010-11 (60 games)

Douglas Murray

2012-13 (14 games, 15 playoff games)

Olli Maatta

2013-14 (78 games, 13 playoff games)
2014-15 (20 games)
2015-16 (67 games, 18 playoff games)
2016-17 (55 games, 25 playoff games)
2017-18 (82 games, 12 playoff games)
​2018-19 (60 games, 1 playoff game)

Jack Johnson

2019-20 (67 games, 4 playoff games)